TROPHY...or Bay Liner!

I was going to buy a trophy, 10 year hull warrantee, great looking, load's of extras... Then i read some stuff on the net about them lining the bay's, On the bottom that is etc, etc... Are thay just a bit jealous or is there something to this? How can some of these boats be disasters and others fantastic if they are all off the same line? They say entry level boat hu, new it would be the most expensive thing i own apart for my house. If I am to buy one new, I want to know that my toy is a safe one, not just pretty. Are these boats any good? Heard some folk (owners) that they are fantastic ra ra, also heard some horror stories of how they have neally sunk as new. I have also read that I am better off spending my money buying the hull I want, doing it up and re-powering with a 4 stroke. I would love to hear some stories, good or bad of your experiences first hand with any model of these trophies. At the moment I am re-doing a small Baron Sportsman (19ft), but eventually would love to buy a new boat, just very scared of spending that much money and being crushed with disappointment. I don't expect to make money when buying a new boat, but have to know I am safe and that there are some sort of workmanship standards. All comments appreciated. Cheers, Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT


alfred's picture

Posts: 3097

Date Joined: 12/01/07

If you are buying new, most

Sat, 2009-09-05 19:52

If you are buying new, most dealers will take your for a sea trial if you are serious. Some will even take you fishing in the model of your choice. You have to decide what you want to spend as that narrows the playing field. No boat will be 100% what you want. Just bear that in mind.

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

Cheers Alfred.... The main

Sat, 2009-09-05 20:04

Cheers Alfred.... The main issues for me are build quality, build quality and build quality, also maybe hull thickness and stringer quality. as far as the boat goes itself, the design is very sensible and comfortable, has just about everything I need. Avante here in Perth offered to take me out in one when I am ready, but I have been put off a bit with all the things I have read over the last year or so, rubbishing Bayliner, Brunswick Corp., Trophy and just about anything else that comes under that roof. My wife and I went to Northshore boats in Perth and saw a prototype 23ft Walkaround that was still in 2 pieces. Being locally built, you could have watched it come together and known that it was done properly and your way, o even closer to being the 100% individual suitability that we all chase, even if you had to pay a bit extra.

We are looking at our budget range of between $60k and $80k so we have been looking at Haines 650 Classics and Patriots (a bit our of our $ range tho), Trophies, and Northshore boats so far.  Any other suggestions?

Cheers, Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

shammy's picture

Posts: 231

Date Joined: 03/07/09

Northshore

Sat, 2009-09-05 20:11

Mate, go and have a chat with Paul at Northshore, he's got a 7.6 in the yard at the moment which may be in your price range.

____________________________________________________________________________

"Life wasn't meant to be a spectator sport"

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

new boat

Sat, 2009-09-05 20:18

Shammy is that boat a walkaround.. He had a unfinished one out front... He make's some of the best local boats i have seen... Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

Posts: 401

Date Joined: 03/01/09

iv got a hainse patriot 680,

Sat, 2009-09-05 23:04

iv got a hainse patriot 680, great boat does everything i want it to, might be a bit out of your budget coming in i think around 110 000, the trophys are a really nice and seem to be finshed off great, i doubt if you are spending 80k on a brand new fiberlgass boat thats its going to quite simply fall apart on you if thats what your worried about, your other opion is ally you get alot of boat for your money but in my opinion if your after a nice riding boat then you just wont get it out of an ally once you have been down the fiberglass road

____________________________________________________________________________

 

 

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

PATRIOT 680

Sat, 2009-09-05 23:16

Thanks Luke... Your boat would be magic, I got on board one at the boat show very nice indeed but you are right it is a bit over my budget..I'm getting to old for ally the back and knee's would not be happy. Do you know any trophy owners? .. Never know lotto has to be one by some one ? cheers Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

alfred's picture

Posts: 3097

Date Joined: 12/01/07

I am not current with boat

Sat, 2009-09-05 23:18

I am not current with boat prices, but I dont think there are any 6m plus Trophys for that kind of money. Having said that, you do get alot of boat for what you pay, with the Trophys. If you do a sea trial, pick a crap day to go out, then you will get a good feel for the boat and you will get to experience first hand what to expect when you go offshore.

I believe Jersey has a used center consul Grady White on the market. Might be worth checking out.

Alot of boat manufactures claim that their products have flotation and some even say they have level flotation. You have to take that with a pinch of salt. Level flotation is often bare boat. Once you have a t top or hard top, gear, outboard with the weight up high (power head location), the CG changes and with the sail effect of anything above the water line it will be quite hard to maintain level flotation in most open waters, unless it's near glass off conditions, which happens, but is rare here in WA.

Most boats will sink if they take on lots of water, the amount of flotation is usually calculated at the weight of an empty boat -generally the more available space you have, the more you carry. Most boats with "level" flotation will keep some part of the boat out of the water, but not necessarily upright. If you can accept that, then the choices get easier.

Of the local boats, I like the Northshores and Haines Patriots. You probably will be able to get more custom work done with the Northshores as they are locally made.

You still haven't mentioned what your intended use is.

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

Alfred

Sun, 2009-09-06 00:06

Fishing, Fishing and Nothing but Fishing.. The best use I know of... The Northshore guy's are really nice to deal with.. They do any and all custom work... trophy's at Avante starting price for 20ft was $62k for the basics, Avante want top dollar even for their second hand boats. After hearing some of the horror stories I don't think I could buy a Trophy unless purchased a relatively new one then spend a fortune strengthening the hull and correcting their other supposed problems. It would make much more sense to get Northshore to build another Walkaround if they still have the mold for Walkaround deck I saw 3 years ago. I will let you know what happens because I will be phoning them on Monday to make some inquiries. Cheers Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

HuggyB's picture

Posts: 2515

Date Joined: 03/08/08

Commodore Marine?

Sun, 2009-09-06 02:00

A 670 Allrounder should slip into your budget....

____________________________________________________________________________

                    The Terrorist - coming to a fishing spot near you.........

kane's picture

Posts: 1752

Date Joined: 07/12/08

Trophys

Sun, 2009-09-06 02:09

An older American workmate of mine whos a keen fisherman based from Florida has told me all about the trophys.

Reckons in the states they were built as a budget package to get your average family on the water. They were mass produced as a one stop shop type boat to buy and turn the key and go - obviously compared to alot of boats in Aus they are still a really nice boat.

I was giving the guy a bit of a questioning on them as I was also interested in one of them about a year ago...

He says the newer ones are good due to a change of ownership, he reccommended to me to not buy anything older than about the 1998, before this he said they did have a tendency to break up and as you say lie on the bottom of the ocean.

____________________________________________________________________________

Gooooone Fishin!

alfred's picture

Posts: 3097

Date Joined: 12/01/07

I agree HuggyB that

Sun, 2009-09-06 09:06

I agree HuggyB that Commodore Marine will be worth a look as well. Have not been on one on the water, but have heard good things about them.

Do you plan to overnite or is it just day trips? If you plan on weekends away, a cab is nice to have. If not a center consul will do.

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

Who makes 670 all rounder..

Sun, 2009-09-06 13:40

Who makes 670 all rounder.. is that a commodore boat ? Have not had a close look at any commodore's as yet..YES,to overnight's...I like a cab even a half cab like my Baron.. Realy taken a liking to most walkaround style boats like Cobia,Mustang,Trophy... and the best one [for me] so far, The walkaround i saw at NORTHSHORE about 2 or 3 years ago... Stunning boat.The owner was a top guy, He made time to go thru a'lot of question's with me and nothing seemed to hard for him.. thanks for the input guy's....Cheer's Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

HuggyB's picture

Posts: 2515

Date Joined: 03/08/08

Yes the 670 Allrounder is by Commodore Marine

Sun, 2009-09-06 14:09

But if you are keen on a walkaround, maybe the Danny Green 685 walkaround by Commodore Marine might be a better option? I think the Rat project would be well beyond your budget.

Not sure if anyone has them here (or if they still make them?), but a friend in Sydney had a Haines Hunter Prowler 650 that was a walkaround and you could sleep in the cabin as an overnighter (I wouldn't want to spend anymore than a night in it though). That wasn't a bad boat fishing wise either.

Not sure if it particularly has to be a glass boat, but in the ali boats there are plenty to choose from such as Genesis, Chivers, Coraline and any number of custom boat builders around Perth to name but a few.

____________________________________________________________________________

                    The Terrorist - coming to a fishing spot near you.........

shammy's picture

Posts: 231

Date Joined: 03/07/09

not a walk around

Sun, 2009-09-06 19:18

But give him a call and have a chat.

____________________________________________________________________________

"Life wasn't meant to be a spectator sport"

Commodore Marine's picture

Posts: 96

Date Joined: 12/05/08

Just give us a call

Sun, 2009-09-06 20:26

and more than happy to take you out for a spin or take you through the factory to see the build process.

____________________________________________________________________________

Andrew Welch

Commodore Marine

 

kane's picture

Posts: 1752

Date Joined: 07/12/08

Hey Andrew

Sun, 2009-09-06 20:47

Got a guy a few houses down from me on my street in Duncraig has what i think is your 7 metre centre console parked out the front of his house....

Nice looking boat... curious if you know the guy or not? The boat looks fairly new if not brand new when he bought it probable coming up to about year ago now...

____________________________________________________________________________

Gooooone Fishin!

slam's picture

Posts: 168

Date Joined: 09/09/09

Kane

Wed, 2009-09-09 12:54

I am the owner of the c/c in Duncraig. Feel free to pop down & have a beer & discuss commodore's boat.

HuggyB's picture

Posts: 2515

Date Joined: 03/08/08

Far out

Wed, 2009-09-09 14:03

small world!

____________________________________________________________________________

                    The Terrorist - coming to a fishing spot near you.........

kane's picture

Posts: 1752

Date Joined: 07/12/08

Cheers mate,

Wed, 2009-09-09 23:08

Im the guy up the road with the never ending renovation.... nice looking boat mate, absolute ripper!

Will take you up on that beer mate...and let us know if your ever short for a decky :)

____________________________________________________________________________

Gooooone Fishin!

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

Commodore Marine

Sun, 2009-09-06 20:45

Thank's we will give you a call in the week and make a time to come down and have a look... Cheer's Darryl
TOO True Adam !

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

Pete D's picture

Posts: 1681

Date Joined: 07/06/07

Trophy Side

Mon, 2009-09-07 09:35

G’day Darryl

I bought my 2052 Trophy with turbo Diesel 3.5 years ago…looked at the Commodore at the show but they were ‘just’ being made. I’d be seriously looking at them now as an option though.

In terms of the Trophy, as said, they are a mid range boat from the States and hence the finish of them is not up there like the Haines…but that’s what an extra 40K gets you.

The diesel is awesome for range (320NM) – my first trip (25hrs on the clock) was for 7 nights to the Montes – up the West side of Barrow and back down the east side. The Trophy is very capable in any conditions thrown at it. I have not seen a better Walkaround setup on another similar sized boat then the Trophy in particular the cabin layout – but this is my opinion based on the fact that ours is a family overnighter (5 nights max so far) as well.

If the boat is to be purely used for fishing, then better might be out there, like the Commodore (I’d go the Rat if my numbers come up!).

If you do go down the Trophy path, contact me for the nitty and gritty.

Cheers Pete

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

PETE"S TROPHY

Mon, 2009-09-07 23:40

Nice to hear Pete.. At last a bit more of a positive story for the Trophy.. With all i have heard, Even when buying NEW it is still money well spent to have it fully checked over by a pro....Cool...

 Cheer's  Darryl

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

shammy's picture

Posts: 231

Date Joined: 03/07/09

Diesel?

Tue, 2009-09-08 14:15

Pete, how big is the tank for that sort of range?

____________________________________________________________________________

"Life wasn't meant to be a spectator sport"

Pete D's picture

Posts: 1681

Date Joined: 07/06/07

320 litres shammy, so about

Tue, 2009-09-08 15:19

320 litres shammy, so about 1nm per litre depending on load.

You can fill it up for me if you want to checkWink

Cheers Pete

grayzeee's picture

Posts: 2283

Date Joined: 09/07/09

i have a haines hunter 600

Tue, 2009-09-08 16:55

i have a haines hunter 600 classic

and i'd def recommend having a look at seafarer

i looked at northshore but their more a compromise leasure fisher

____________________________________________________________________________

If I spent half as long fishing , as I do reading this bloody forum , I'd be twice the fisherman I am. 

grayzeee's picture

Posts: 2283

Date Joined: 09/07/09

go a recent used boat in

Tue, 2009-09-08 16:57

go a recent used boat in bigger size over new smaller boat

you'll still need to change loads in a new boat

____________________________________________________________________________

If I spent half as long fishing , as I do reading this bloody forum , I'd be twice the fisherman I am. 

solly's picture

Posts: 375

Date Joined: 11/09/05

Check out Tournament(Mustang)

Tue, 2009-09-08 22:23

I just picked up my Tournament 2250 bluewater and whilst I was there another fellow was picking up his 2250 walkaround.I had a good look at his boat and its a real quality walkaround ,the price was just over $90000 with a 200 etec but he had a fair few extras put on as well.The dealer will bend over backwards for you and is a straight shooter.(Waterworld)I can testfiy that the hull is a excellent ride as its the same as mine it also has a large cabin for the overnight stay and a 300litre fuel tank.

Cheers

Solly

____________________________________________________________________________

There are two types of people ,do'ers and watchers
Right now the do'ers are the doing it
And the watchers are watching us do it

HuggyB's picture

Posts: 2515

Date Joined: 03/08/08

Have to agree

Wed, 2009-09-09 14:04

never riden on one, but I am in wangara a lot and I do like the look of those 2250 Bluewaters. They looked to really well finished from the ones I saw.

____________________________________________________________________________

                    The Terrorist - coming to a fishing spot near you.........

mako magic's picture

Posts: 5785

Date Joined: 03/08/05

yeah i had my eyes on one of

Wed, 2009-09-09 14:50

yeah i had my eyes on one of them before the commodore came up, very nice looking well set up boat

damo6230's picture

Posts: 2029

Date Joined: 07/06/08

go local

Thu, 2009-09-10 00:01

When last at Mandurah boat show the best stand was commodore. They let me drool and answered all my questions....

Lived in America and one has to understand capatilism to understand quality.

If I ever have enough $$ I would not hesitate to purchase a commodore for there fraser's  

but good luck and enjoy the moment

Posts: 6

Date Joined: 11/07/09

Have a look at a Seaswirl

Mon, 2009-09-14 21:23

Have a look at a Seaswirl.  They make a very nice boat which come pretty well spec'd.  We imported a 2101WA with a 200hp Yamaha on an ali trailer and saved heaps.  I'd agree with Grayzeee.........get a near newie and pocket the difference.

John

____________________________________________________________________________

Importers of high quality, luxury sports cruisers and trailer boats

               [email protected] / 0411204133 

slam's picture

Posts: 168

Date Joined: 09/09/09

I agree

Tue, 2009-09-15 10:59

Yeh, i reckon thats the way to go aswell. You can pick up a great boat a few yrs old with under 100hrs on the engine.

fishcrazy's picture

Posts: 1235

Date Joined: 27/01/07

trophy

Tue, 2009-09-22 13:06

a mate of mine has a trophy with a 175 outboard ive taken it out a few times not impresssed at all

Posts: 112

Date Joined: 04/09/09

Why .....

Fri, 2009-09-25 19:51

What were its fault's....Cool

____________________________________________________________________________

 

NEVER TRUST ANY GOVERNMENT

Posts: 6

Date Joined: 11/07/09

Trophy 1903 CC

Tue, 2009-09-29 21:11

My mate has a 2005 Trophy 1903 CC with a Yamaha 150hp and she handles beautifully.  Soft ride, enough power, economical and easy to fish.  I have also been on a Trophy 1952WA with a 4.3ltr mercruiser (190hp) and that was excellent as well.

Was your mates an older boat?

 

PS Bloke who called yesterday about the Seaswirl import call again.  Your number was blocked!

____________________________________________________________________________

Importers of high quality, luxury sports cruisers and trailer boats

               [email protected] / 0411204133 

Posts: 143

Date Joined: 30/08/05

 I had a Trophy 2352

Tue, 2009-09-29 21:23

 I had a Trophy 2352 Walkaround with a mate. No probs and a better ride than most on the Aussie market. Fitted out well with things where you need them.

Posts: 6

Date Joined: 11/07/09

Did yours have the 5ltr Merc?

Tue, 2009-09-29 21:34

The 2352WA is a great sized boat. Our 1952WA was great for us with two little tackers to hold on to. She used to get up and fly easily. I find the 2352Wa a great model and like you say has everything you want. Plenty of power?

____________________________________________________________________________

Importers of high quality, luxury sports cruisers and trailer boats

               [email protected] / 0411204133 

Posts: 143

Date Joined: 30/08/05

Yep

Tue, 2009-09-29 21:41

Yep